Updated July 2026

Indianapolis Colts Fantasy Football Team Names (2026)

Every good Colts fantasy name is either a pun on a Colts star or an inside joke only the fanbase gets. Both lists below.

Indianapolis fans still measure every quarterback against Peyton Manning, which is both a blessing and a curse for whoever wears number 18's old locker. The Colts have cycled through hopefuls since the Luck era ended too soon, but this is a fanbase that remembers a Super Bowl and expects the standard to return. Fantasy names here can lean nostalgic or bet on the next guy up.

Puns on Colts stars

  • Peyton Manning The Fort
  • Anthony Richardson Scale
  • Jonathan Taylor Swift
  • Michael Pittman Jr Mints
  • Andrew Luck Be A Lady
  • Kenny Moore The Merrier
  • DeForest Buckner Pass
  • Quenton Nelson Mandela
  • Josh Downs Under
  • Alec Pierce Brosnan
  • Grover Stewart Little
  • Zaire Franklin Delano Roosevelt
  • Braden Smith College
  • Ryan Kelly Clarkson
  • Bernhard Raimann Noodle
  • Kwity Paye Day
  • Julian Blackmon Pope
  • Samson Ebukam Mic
  • Matt Gay Nineties
  • Adonai Mitchell Report

Colts culture names

  • Horseshoe Theory Believers
  • Lucas Oil Change
  • The Mannings Way
  • Colts Blue Blood
  • RCA Dome Ghosts
  • Chuck Strong Forever
  • Blue Horseshoe Believers
  • Irsay's Twitter Fingers
  • 18 To Infinity
  • Playoff Berth Then Vanish
  • Colt Strut March
  • Circle City Sundays

Names for Colts player pages

Drafted one of these Colts players specifically? Their pages have names built around that pick.

Won big last week? Changing your team name mid-season to something taunting your league after a signature Colts win isn't against the rules — it's practically a tradition.